Work
force diversity: Fact or fad?
How to manage a work force
that is dramatically changing.
©2000
Trisha A. Svehla
he
term "work force diversity" became a buzzword after The Hudson Institute
released its study entitled "Workforce 2000, Work and Workers for
the 21st Century." Based on its statistics, the predominately white
male work force would shrink drastically over the next 10 to 15
years. The white male composition of new job entrants, which historically
was over 47%, would shrink to approximately 15%. This statistic
caught the attention of corporate America, especially in industries
where white male entrants predominated.
A recent study of human resource professionals illustrates the
reality of these figures. Over the period 1983-1993, women in the
work force increased by 69.1%; African-Americans by 59.1%; Hispanics
by 49.4%; Asians by 44.4%; and white males by 10.4%.
What exactly is meant by the term "work force diversity"? Some
diversity scholars have broken out diversity into two categories
primary and secondary. Primary elements of diversity are those which
are inborn and/or exert an important impact on our early socialization.
The primary elements of diversity are age, ethnicity, gender, physical
abilities/qualities, race, sexual orientation and personality type.
Secondary elements of diversity are those that can and are changed
through life. These include-but are not limited to-dimensions such
as educational background, geographic location, income status, marital
status, military experience, parental status, religious beliefs
and work experience.
A combination of both primary and secondary elements of diversity
defines the properties and characteristics that constitute the whole
person. It is these numerous elements of diversity that challenge
today's managers.
As large numbers of women and people of color enter the workplace,
management concepts that have "always" worked begin to fail. Individual
values, workplace expectations, communication styles, management
styles, team concepts, etc. take on dramatically different meanings.
Let's review some of the issues that must be addressed in a changing
workplace.
Good-bye, Ozzie
and Harriet
When the workplace was predominately white male, work and family
issues were nonexistent. But with an increase in the numbers of
women in the workplace, organizations are scrambling to adjust policies
and practices that will make them attractive to this pool of available
talent in a tight labor market. Managers' "Ozzie and Harriet" attitudes
and behaviors that reflect the mentality of family issues as Mom's
responsibility and therefore best left at home are becoming obsolete
and harmful to the effectiveness and viability of most workplace
environments.
Stereotypes that may limit our views of others also have become
a liability. For example, to view Asians solely as technicians,
i.e. "good at math and science," limits the availability of management
talent.
Another limiting liability is viewing women as competent in only
the soft business areas, such as human resources, marketing and
support staff, and not as viable candidates for "hard" business
areas such as finance, new product development, etc. Or perhaps
promotion opportunities for females are limited because of old attitudes
such as "they will get married, have babies and leave."
The generation
gap
Another lament of today's managers is not understanding "this
younger generationwho have no loyalty, work ethic and want
to be president overnight." This issue can be a classic study
in value differentiation's between the silent generation (those
who grew up during the depression), baby boomers (those who grew
up in the prosperous '50s and '60s) and the baby busters (the current
wave of young workplace entrants who grew up in the '70s and '80s).
Many baby busters entered the labor market without the same expectations
of job security and advancement as previous generations. They saw
firsthand the ravages of today's re-engineered, downsized world
with parents laid off without cause; thus they may tend to see every
job as temporary. They tend to speak in terms of "job"
vs. "career."
New
workplace expectations may require managers to redefine the concept
of workplace loyaltyusually defined as hard work and long
hours.
These workplace expectations may require managers to redefine the
concept of workplace loyaltyusually defined as hard work and
long hours. It may mean revising benefit plans to fit with a more
nomadic workplace. One recent study of baby buster expectations
found that when asked what they would change if they could change
one thing, many responded that they would "get rid of the retirement
plan and give us day care or a health center."
Trying to effectively manage in today's complex and diverse world
with yesterday's management attitudes and philosophies is no more
effective than the brontosaurus is in today's ecology. To be successful
in today's global marketplace, managers must learn to understand
and appreciate the many differences and views they'll encounter.
By effectively managing diversity, they can create an environment
that is more creative, adaptable and responsive in meeting today's
customer expectations.
Trisha
A. Svehla is president of Managing The Mosaic in Downers Grove, Ill., specialists in human resources consulting.
She has more than 20 years of experience as a hands-on practitioner
in all aspects of human resources, and holds a master's degree in
management from Northwestern University, Svehla is a frequent keynote
speaker and trainer at national and regional business and association
conferences.
|